Brett Hull’s controversial triple-overtime goal for the 1999 Stanley Cup deserves a deep rewind

  • Published: 04 May 2019
  • In game six of the 1999 Stanley Cup Finals, the Buffalo Sabres hosted the Dallas Stars and no one was aware how long of a night they were in for, or how controversial the finish would be. Both sides were seeking their franchise's first Stanley Cup. Both sides had one of the league's best goaltenders in their net. But only one side had Brett Hull.

    He was the final piece in a massive makeover the Stars had gone through since their arrival in Dallas a few seasons earlier. Along with Mike Modano, Jere Lehtinen, and Joe Nieuwendyk, Hull was in good company when it came to scoring goals. But tonight, and this whole series, it was tougher sledding thanks to Dominik Hasek. That isn't to say it was all smooth sailing for the Dominator; Hasek just wouldn't be rattled regardless of the weapons he faced. Outside of game two, he was giving up less than two goals per game. The trouble was his offense faced just as tough of a test when trying to get pucks past Belfour.

    So in triple-overtime, still tied at 1-1, Hull gave us a moment in history that is still held onto by both franchises - just for polar opposite reasons.

    Written and produced by Will Buikema
    Directed and edited by Joe Ali

    5:07 - Sabres were 7th seed, not 6th seed
    8:57 - Lehtinen, not Nieuwendyk


    Check out our full video catalog:
    Visit our playlists:
    Like SB Nation on Facebook:
    Follow on Twitter:
    Follow on Instagram:
    Explore SB Nation:
  • Sport Sport

Comments • 909

  • Pontius Pilate
    Pontius Pilate  3 days back

    Change the intro to "if Dallas wins, they win be headed to
    Vinnie Paul's house to party with strippers and a cases of crown Royal where the cup will get thrown off his balcony and get a big dent in it".
    RIP Vinny and Dimebag!!!

    • AlrightByMondayMusic
      AlrightByMondayMusic  3 days back

      This goal is one of my first hockey memories at 8 years old actually understanding the game and the new rule implemented and how that was thrown out the window for this goal lol

      • king quark
        king quark  1 weeks back

        nolan slept with haseks wife

        • Sean Hanlins Daddy
          Sean Hanlins Daddy  2 weeks back

          86 Super Bowl 9ers vs Bengals deserves a second look

          • Matthew Kurosky
            Matthew Kurosky  3 weeks back

            See now stop complaining

            • Chase Bahne
              Chase Bahne  4 weeks back

              No goal.

              • KarlTheKiller_Gamer
                KarlTheKiller_Gamer  4 weeks back

                And now the sabers suck

                • Ykcin978
                  Ykcin978  4 weeks back

                  Please do Alex Burrows's OT winner game 7 vs hawks 2011

                  • Helix Gaming - Gaming/Vlogs king

                    Game 7 eastern conference final 2017. I was laying in bed hoping the penguins will lose in double over time. Not able to fall asleep i here the goal horn go off. That means the home team won. I was pissed. They ended up winning the cup

                    • pandoralover21
                      pandoralover21  1 months back

                      still disgusting that texas would ever steal a hockey team from minnesota

                      • sean mcphail
                        sean mcphail  1 months back

                        Hasek wasn’t happy with Nolan cuz Nolan was sleeping with his wife.

                        • William Fetters
                          William Fetters  1 months back

                          The worst part of this whole thing is that they called that damn " Skate In the Crease" rule super tight that ENTIRE year.
                          I'd love to see how many times it was called across the leauge through out the season cause it was definitely a ton of them. The top rule makers n the NHL told all the referees to keep a very close eye on it & call it everytime.

                          So for that to happen all year long & then have the season end in triple overtime on a goal where the skate was in the crease , no doubt about it , that just terrible.

                          The rule was immediately changed back to normal. That was for the better IMO. It was a terrible rule.

                          • Jay Lew
                            Jay Lew  2 months back

                            I wonder if they checked if his wrist was game worthy how Emilio checked Adam Banks wrist in the locker room

                            • opiered51
                              opiered51  2 months back

                              Man I remember staying up late as hell watching this

                              • robert perrella
                                robert perrella  2 months back

                                in the 1940's,1950's,1960's,1970.s1980.s: the brett hull hgoal would have counted IN THOSE DAYS!!!!!!!!!the goal should count for another reason: PITIFUL DEFENSIVE ZONE COVERAGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

                                • jeff weaver
                                  jeff weaver  2 months back

                                  No goal

                                  • Angel Morales
                                    Angel Morales  2 months back

                                    Do a rewinder for the 04 Red Sox Comeback or the Cavs Comeback

                                    • Ryan Ahr
                                      Ryan Ahr  2 months back

                                      This came up after the erroneously named "Music City Miracle" video for me. I'm from Buffalo and have been a fan from birth. Just...ouch.

                                      • david Ash
                                        david Ash  2 months back

                                        The rule was changed ur a sports show sad

                                        • Jennapher Hague
                                          Jennapher Hague  2 months back

                                          Damn good! Props for the tee, too! And it was a silly rule; protect the goalies, yes! But of course it’s gonna result in fewer goals, silly wabbitts!
                                          And a vid on 1972 USA/USSR gold medal game would be awesome! None of the USA players accepted their silver medals after the outrageous outcome!!

                                          • RickAwesomeGaming
                                            RickAwesomeGaming  3 months back

                                            Game 7 of the Flames-Lightning Stanley Cup Final definitely needs a rewind, especially considering the controversy behind it.

                                            • TheWumboTrolley
                                              TheWumboTrolley  3 months back

                                              We need more hockey and Will. Here’s more things you should do:

                                              Crosby’s Golden Goal in the 2010 Olympics
                                              Fleury’s save on Lidstrom in 2009 Game 7
                                              Kane’s goal in Game 6 of the 2010 Finals
                                              Alec Martinez’s Cup Winner in 2014
                                              Chris Kunitz sends Ottawa to hell in 2017 Eastern Conference Finals
                                              Rangers ‘94 Cup Run
                                              Just do more hockey.

                                              • Derek Lasker
                                                Derek Lasker  3 months back

                                                No goal

                                                • Jake Reed
                                                  Jake Reed  3 months back

                                                  Boo you stars, boo you

                                                  • E93 Sports
                                                    E93 Sports  3 months back

                                                    the third time buffalo and dallas faced each other for a championship. only this time it's in hockey.

                                                    • DJ Tommy C.
                                                      DJ Tommy C.  3 months back

                                                      It’s pronounced Gay

                                                      • Malik Von Saint
                                                        Malik Von Saint  3 months back

                                                        No goal.

                                                        Been yelling that from parking lot of Marine Midland Arena in '99. Now you can find me all weathered and homeless

                                                        • Kevin Brown
                                                          Kevin Brown  3 months back

                                                          the curse of buffalo, but hey your kings of snow

                                                          • Ryan G.
                                                            Ryan G.  3 months back

                                                            This is akin to watching a snuff film in Buffalo. Still hurts like it did, even 20 years later.

                                                            • Pete Gall
                                                              Pete Gall  3 months back

                                                              Man I loved Hasek. He was so unique. From his style over all Down to his helmet.

                                                              • David Gonzalez
                                                                David Gonzalez  4 months back

                                                                OK. So, I can finally get this understood: The rule stated that if a player has possession of the puck and goes into the crease, as long as there isn't a change of possession, the goal will count. Brett Hull shot the puck and went into the crease to get the rebound. Because there was not a change of possession, Hull was able to get his own rebound and score, while inside the crease. Does this make sense? I just finally want to understand what the rules say.

                                                                • Deetrain
                                                                  Deetrain  4 months back

                                                                  Eddy the eagle man. The guy wasn't as good as Patrick, marty or the dominator...but he was right there behind them and came up.big imin 99 and 2000

                                                                  • Carson
                                                                    Carson  4 months back

                                                                    4:03 The newspaper reporters predicted the flyers mascot! GRITTY

                                                                    • Jamie Kargus
                                                                      Jamie Kargus  4 months back

                                                                      20 years ago today this happened (June 20th 1999-June 20th 2019) @Sabres fans get over it.

                                                                      • Mannina90
                                                                        Mannina90  4 months back

                                                                        the way you say "didn't" irks me

                                                                        • Conner Begeman
                                                                          Conner Begeman  4 months back

                                                                          Brett hull would of gotten his cup if he played with the blues on Wednesday

                                                                          • untexan
                                                                            untexan  4 months back

                                                                            I remember when this rule was in place. Everyone in the NHL and the hockey media made such a big deal about absolutely no skates in the crease. This goal was a logical exception to the rule — of course you can play the puck in the crease, why wouldn’t you be able to do that? But no one ever heard about it because of all the ZERO TOLERANCE messaging.

                                                                            By the way, the Sabres exited the playoffs the year before on a eerily similar play by Brian Bellows and Joey Juneau of the Capitals. Check this out:

                                                                            • MMGJ10
                                                                              MMGJ10  4 months back

                                                                              Somehow I completely forgot Minnesota changed from North Stars to just the Stars.... How do I not remember this?

                                                                              • Alanzo Veach
                                                                                Alanzo Veach  4 months back

                                                                                do a rewind on the blues this year

                                                                                • Ultrametric
                                                                                  Ultrametric  4 months back

                                                                                  This is unlistenable.

                                                                                  • Detective Biggles
                                                                                    Detective Biggles  4 months back

                                                                                    The North Stars Cinderella Run in the 1991 playoffs would be a good rewind.

                                                                                    • BravesAvsFan
                                                                                      BravesAvsFan  4 months back

                                                                                      Sadly, Buffalo fans haven't gotten to see their team reach the Finals since then. Dominik Hasek, on the other hand, would eventually get his name on the Cup 3 years later as a member of the Red Wings...with Brett Hull as one of his teammates.

                                                                                      • Henry 717
                                                                                        Henry 717  5 months back

                                                                                        The refs were tired

                                                                                        • Rick Moran
                                                                                          Rick Moran  5 months back

                                                                                          I hate to say it, as a Sabres fan, but after years of thinking this is "no goal" I've changed my mind. I don't buy the argument that after the puck touches Hasek it's still Hull's puck, no it's a loose puck at best, maybe even Hasek's puck. However, I do consider it Hull's puck when he kicks it up to his stick, and if you pause the video at the exact moment he kicks the puck, he is completely out of the crease and despite the fact that he re-enters the crease, he does so with the puck and therefore you have a good goal. For those of us that watched hockey that year, the rule was really dumb, but you got used to it, goals were disallowed all the time, it was part of the game that year. So at first it did seem like "no goal" because I had never before slowed it down to watch him kick the puck, but he does so intentionally, it's a hockey play, it didn't just bounce to him, therefore a goal.

                                                                                          • Eric Silver
                                                                                            Eric Silver  5 months back

                                                                                            You should do "the creation of SB nation deserves a deep rewind"

                                                                                            • Shawn Baker
                                                                                              Shawn Baker  5 months back

                                                                                              Freaking love these rewinds!! They are very informative!!!

                                                                                              • Jo Bckts
                                                                                                Jo Bckts  5 months back

                                                                                                3 OTs means: just Hit the Post, We end this manaujury.

                                                                                                • RyanMiller3039
                                                                                                  RyanMiller3039  5 months back

                                                                                                  The Sabres got screwed, no goal.