Does God exist? Neil deGrasse Tyson and Michio Kaku Debate - The Best Documentary Ever

Share
HTML-code

Comments • 2 316

  • Joe Dustin
    Joe Dustin  7 hours back

    But the real question..... what does God need with a Starship?

    • Raymond Stemmer
      Raymond Stemmer  7 hours back

      Does God exist ? It depends on your meaning of God. God exist if it's the unexplainable things of our exsistance ! If it's the father of Jesus or Mohammed's Allah then God doesn't exist & is a man made thing or he's shy and hide behind clouds & tortures & kills everything ! He's always on the side of warriors, both sides !

      • Joyce Gentile
        Joyce Gentile  19 hours back

        Just because N D Tyson has doubts does not make him bad!

        • PassionateAmateur
          PassionateAmateur  20 hours back

          You ain’t fooling no one Tyson nugget. All y’all the same in Hollywood you believe in satan after all you worship him so obviously you believe in GOD stop 😂.

          • Majed Jastaneiah
            Majed Jastaneiah  21 hours back

            He always uses the same reason when asked if he beleives in a god, always brings up the natural disasters. God is the allmighty and all powerful, everything on this earth and on top of it is made by God, if a volcano killed 100,000 its God’s will, if its raining in the desert its God’s will, if an ant is eating its God’s will. Be thankful that you are still alive and well, do ur good deeds and wish to god that you dont get killed in an earth quick.

            • Ray D
              Ray D  1 days back

              True true true f... True

              • legitgreatness
                legitgreatness  1 days back

                Most religions are based on stupidity, the true is that we haven't discovered our real purpose in this universe.

                • Bobby Brian
                  Bobby Brian  2 days back

                  Maybe the earth is the proof of god ? How come this planet are so friendly with as ? Mmm , Maybe the earth and our lives are a miracle , I always wonder how come we cannot find a sign of life on another planets

                  • Red Rebel
                    Red Rebel  3 days back

                    If living and death is in God's hand , how come life expectancy is increasing with the advancement of medical facilities ???

                    • Sidney Hemphill
                      Sidney Hemphill  4 hours back

                      @Raymond Stemmer lol hey I'm just saying what people could argue.

                    • Raymond Stemmer
                      Raymond Stemmer  7 hours back

                      Because GOD Said SO ! GOD made disease, bot flys & torture !

                    • Sidney Hemphill
                      Sidney Hemphill  8 hours back

                      One could argue that medical advancement is the work God through the people making it so.

                  • Dwayne Shaw
                    Dwayne Shaw  3 days back

                    Jesus is his own daddy and he lives in the sky - QED (thus it is shown what kind of bullshit people will swallow)

                    • Carol Mosher
                      Carol Mosher  4 days back

                      There is incontrovertible scientific evidence for the existence of God.

                      • Carol Mosher
                        Carol Mosher  4 days back

                        There is incontrovertible scientific evidence for the existence of God.

                        • Carol Mosher
                          Carol Mosher  2 days back

                          @Michael Schneider It's not just claims. It's scientific evidence. Do you claim that what I have presented is not scientific evidence? Yes or no?

                        • Michael Schneider
                          Michael Schneider  2 days back

                          Claims require evidence. I guess you are not interested in making a logically true argument. You know nothing about me, yet resort to name calling. Typical of someone with no argument.

                        • Michael Schneider
                          Michael Schneider  2 days back

                          Carol Mosher
                          Sorry, claims are not evidence.

                        • Dwayne Shaw
                          Dwayne Shaw  3 days back

                          and yet you don't actually cite a single example? Btw. even if your claim wasn't a flat out lie - proof of "A GOD" would not be proof of "YOUR GOD" - for instance it is very clear that the Judeo-Christian God, with a 6000 year old Creation myth, is utter bullshit. Not to mention the FACT that the Judeo -Christian God is, according to the Bible, evil - condoning genocide, slaughtering innocent infant babies, slavery, and rape.

                      • Antonio Crosby
                        Antonio Crosby  4 days back

                        This is not a Debate and Neil never said that God did not exist he simply saying who knows the thoughts or the mind of God

                        • jokeybob
                          jokeybob  1 days back

                          Neil once was an atheist, but recently says he don't know. PR people.

                      • Ryan
                        Ryan  4 days back

                        Neil says: "god is an ever receding pocket of scientific ignorance!" BURN!! 10:20

                        • Carol Mosher
                          Carol Mosher  22 hours back

                          ​@jokeybob said, "Man can't create a Neutrino from nothing. " Not now, maybe later. -"

                          That’s speculation. I am only dealing with science and in that sense what we can observe, test, and measure right now.

                          ​ jokeybob said "The smallest detectable...." No Proof for your conclusion -> "Neutrinos required a "Higher Power""

                          The facts are this. The smallest detectable fundamental particles that make up Neutrinos that existed before the big bang, referred to as “light Neutrinos” have 168-169 micro-electron-volts or (μeV). This is factoring in an uncertainty of ±2 μeV. This data set is from experiments at the Princeton Tritium Observatory for Light. And data from the Planck satellite. These “light neutrinos” are part of the radiation field that existed before the red hot big bang. Now, Neutrinos that are observed and measured today, in the Hadron Collider for example, have billions of time more energy. We know from elementary particle physics that relies on conservation laws and E = mc2 that lower energy particles can’t transform into the mass of higher-energy particles without a Higher Power to fuse the transformation. Thus, the smallest detectable fundamental particles that make up Neutrinos required a "Higher Power" above and beyond the universe to be created.

                        • jokeybob
                          jokeybob  1 days back

                          @Carol Mosher "Man can't create a Neutrino from nothing. " Not now, maybe later. - and "4. The smallest detectable...." No Proof for your conclusion -> "Neutrinos required a "Higher Power"". Most importantly this and' the big bang needs a creator' In no way yields a loving god or one that needs worshiping.

                        • Carol Mosher
                          Carol Mosher  2 days back

                          ​@Michael Schneider
                          Michael Schneider said None of these qualify!

                          That's just your opinion based on your atheist religious faith/beliefs. You need objective scientific tests to invalidate scientific evidence.

                          Michael Schneider , “How know it takes a god to create a neutrino?”

                          I didn’t say, “it takes a god to create a neutrino.”

                          Michael Schneider , “These are not testable or evidence.”

                          Even denying it's science or evidence requires scientific test results to be valid. Otherwise any atheist fool can look at any science and simply say, that's not science. And I would like to think you are not a fool. So have you conducted any tests, or can you cite any test results that invalidate the claims?

                          Michael Schneider , “They are unsubstantiated claims.”

                          Actually, the facts are this. The smallest detectable fundamental particles that make up Neutrinos that existed before the big bang, referred to as “light Neutrinos” have 168-169 micro-electron-volts or (μeV). This is factoring in an an uncertainty of ±2 μeV. This data set is from experiments at the Princeton Tritium Observatory for Light. And data from the Planck satellite. These “light neutrinos” are part of the radiation field that existed before the red hot big bang. Now, Neutrinos that are observed and measured today, in the Hadron Collider for example, have billions of time more energy. We know from elementary particle physics that relies on conservation laws and E = mc2 that lower energy particles can’t transform into the mass of higher-energy particles without a Higher Power to fuse the transformation. Thus, the smallest detectable fundamental particles that make up Neutrinos required a "Higher Power" above and beyond the universe to be created.

                        • Michael Schneider
                          Michael Schneider  2 days back

                          Carol Mosher
                          None of these qualify! How know it takes a god to create a neutrino? These are not testable or evidence. They are unsubstantiated claims.

                        • Carol Mosher
                          Carol Mosher  2 days back

                          @Michael Schneider The following testable scientific claims present incontrovertible scientific evidence ( though not proof) of the existence of God, where God is operationally defined as a "Higher Power" above and beyond all time and space or the Universe.

                          1. Man can't create a Neutrino from nothing.
                          2. Neutrinos do not create themselves from nothing.
                          3. The fundamental particles that make up Neutrinos have not always existed.
                          4. The smallest detectable fundamental particles that make up Neutrinos required a "Higher Power" above and beyond the universe to be created.

                      • Kam Mueller
                        Kam Mueller  4 days back

                        Einstein made it simply clear. His view on God was there was no such thing as any God. Yet every idiot around wants to put words in his mouth now that he is dead.

                        • Kamal Rahman
                          Kamal Rahman  4 days back

                          When people's understanding of God fails them--God works in a mistryous way.

                          • ILL Ones
                            ILL Ones  4 days back

                            Tyson a fuckin idiot wen it comes to god..not sayin i do or don't believe but this guys fuckin thoughts on the subject was FUCKING excruciating!!! Smh

                            • Zerai Andegeorgs
                              Zerai Andegeorgs  4 days back

                              What is consistent is science continues to unravel mystery. I suppose Neil just said that.

                              • FISSEHA KEBEDE
                                FISSEHA KEBEDE  5 days back

                                I agree completely with Mr. DeGrasse tyson believe in what you want but don't impose your belief on any one, Freedom of religion means is not only to believe but not to believe too. I believe in dog reversing god, because the dog will be there for me unconditionally. My dog is love, fair, just and true friend.

                                • fred
                                  fred  5 days back

                                  That's a very stupid question.
                                  A Fraud that was put upon people by ass holes.

                                  • sandra ewurum
                                    sandra ewurum  5 days back

                                    Mr scientist, please with all the physics and equations please we are waiting for you guys to create another plant and then create life from inception

                                    • 1rcproductions
                                      1rcproductions  5 days back

                                      I dislike a video that is an edited mash up of various videos that can be presented in a way to present the biased view of the editor. This is a fail based on the title. This is not a real time debate.

                                      • renegade_ace
                                        renegade_ace  5 days back

                                        Thumbs down cause not a debate

                                        • Kelly Holloran
                                          Kelly Holloran  5 days back

                                          God is unreadable

                                          • Kelly Holloran
                                            Kelly Holloran  5 days back

                                            God does exist.

                                            • D.E.B. B
                                              D.E.B. B  5 days back

                                              While we cannot say for certain that a god does not exist, what we definitely CAN say, is that a god, as described in all known religions so far, does not exist, because the existence of such a god or gods, is inconsistent with the state of the world and the universe as we know it.

                                              • Dwayne Shaw
                                                Dwayne Shaw  3 days back

                                                @bro dough -I'm not talking about bad things that happen. I'm talking about YOUR EVIL GOD DEMANDING THE SLAUGHTER OF INFANT BABIES (Numbers 31:1-18 -as one example) YOU KEEP AVOIDING THAT FACT. Same with genocide, slavery ,and rape. I'm not talking about these things just happening in society I AM TALKING ABOUT YOUR BIBLE AND YOUR GOD DEMANDING AND CONDONING THESE DISCPICABLE ACTS - ya double talking hypocrite.
                                                But, since you carry on like a corrupt politician, writing chapters to pivot and avoid answering very a very straight forward question. Let's stick with ONE THING AT A TIME. - Numbers 31:1-18. How do you justify your evil god demanding the genocidal slaughter of innocent little infant babies? Can you make an actual relevant point? Are you too chicken shit to address what the Bible actually says rather than bloviate abstract bullshit?

                                              • bro dough
                                                bro dough  3 days back

                                                @Dwayne Shaw  My initial instinct was to laugh at your reply cause you called my God evil as if you're righteous and holy, but then decided to go and say such a thing about me when you have no clue who I am or how I handle myself.

                                                Still, you don't understand. It's not God who is doing terrible things, nor is God not Good. You speak of genocide, who's fault is that? Slavery? Rape? Is it REALLY God doing this type of work against us? No, you're wrong. It's man. It's people who are selfish, and desire things of the world. It's power, pleasure, money, etc. Just think about your own life. Do you desire any of these things over God? Or do you lie? I know I'm like all of these things. That is why I need Christ. All of humans are and the Bible says so. That's why we all need Christ.

                                                The death of babies in accidents are tragic and shouldn't happen but they do. Many natural disasters happen and they kill hundreds of people. Dont people need salvation moreso then? You talk about God like He is the root of all of the problems in the world; as in, He desires death upon all of the people of the world...in which I cannot agree on with you.

                                                If you were to talk about suffering in the world and speak humbly about the one and only God, Jesus Christ, yearning for peace in the world, for salvation from this broken world... Then I'd be on board with you. I'm not right now, but I hope to change your mind so we're in the same boat.

                                                I do understand why you would think the way you do though. You may ask, "Why would God allow all these things to happen? If you're so powerful God, then why not just snap your fingers and make everything perfect?"

                                                It's natural and I sometimes think this too. But that question that we ask God is really a retorical question. As in we don't know. But we do know to trust in the Lord.

                                                It seems far out to just believe in something that you can't see and fully know that is there and know that is true....but the Bible even says, "Who has faith in what he has seen? Faith is believing what is unseen." Which makes sense. How much more would you have a true faith if you really believe in this even if there are unanswered questions or tough questions. Especially ones like, how will neurologically disabled people be saved if they can't understand to declare in their heart that Jesus is Lord? I still struggle with this question and I'm not sure on how to go on about answering it in a way that alligns with God's word.

                                                But at the same time, who are we as humans to question God's ways and the people He creates?

                                                Just some thoughts.

                                              • Dwayne Shaw
                                                Dwayne Shaw  3 days back

                                                @bro dough - my thoughts are "you will know them by their fruits" A God that commits, condones and commands genocide, slavery, and rape is an evil God. And anyone that worships an evil God is a morally bankrupt moron. If you think it's ok to slaughter babies- stay the hell away from everybody's children - ya reprobate

                                            • Abhishek Constantine Winchester Roy

                                              Universe is matter and energy which needs a controller to create animate and inanimate.

                                              • NanohFN
                                                NanohFN  6 days back

                                                Ok look, what's the main purpose religion was made?

                                                To explain the unexplainable.

                                                So, in native religion and earlier religions, gods or god control the natural disasters. So a volcano would be god being mad at so nothing or someone.

                                                But its simple science, earthquakes happen because faults sliding past each another cause vibrations and creates seismic activity. And volcanoes is just Earth and it's processes.

                                                • Chigozie Odili
                                                  Chigozie Odili  6 days back

                                                  A foolish man is always foolish. Simply because you've not seen your brain, does it mean you have no brain?
                                                  Did cars exist on their own? If man made material things that's enough reason to know that someone made a man.

                                                  • Chigozie Odili
                                                    Chigozie Odili  6 days back

                                                    Stupid devil worshipers. They said they don't believe in God yet they believe in Satan. Humans are too foolish because they decive themselves a lot.

                                                • De 4 com Vaifilipe
                                                  De 4 com Vaifilipe  6 days back

                                                  Neils statements about religion are equivalent to a flat earthers statements about phisics

                                                  Both have absolutely no clue about what they are talking simply cause theyve never looked for the information, all extremely easily available

                                                  • De 4 com Vaifilipe
                                                    De 4 com Vaifilipe  3 days back

                                                    @Spritzer AK4U their option for ignorance. Both could easily know the truth after a brief research on internet or talking 10 minutes with and expert

                                                  • Spritzer AK4U
                                                    Spritzer AK4U  4 days back

                                                    What excatly are you equating to a flat earth theory though? Many if not most to all flat earth arguments can be determined as false as I hope you know. What does he say that resembles that?

                                                • Sotiris
                                                  Sotiris  6 days back

                                                  O&a

                                                  • Ronny Diehl
                                                    Ronny Diehl  6 days back

                                                    They are approaching the question in the wrong way. They should first question what state of mind is the questioner in. For a Yogi, the concept of God is completely different to a man holding archaic concepts of God as in the judeo Christian and Islamic tradition ( of course within those traditions we can find more 'spiritual' leanings but the scriptures are telling the archaic story no matter what)

                                                    • Simon, the Senior
                                                      Simon, the Senior  6 days back

                                                      I must admit that in my old age I have really noticed just how much the weather is trying to kill me, all the time. Michio Kaku seems to think that he lives inside of a protective bubble that personally protects him from the weather. That makes Michio Kaku delusional from my point of view. Unless you are immortal, like Michio Kaku, then survival is the primary directive of all life forms. Thus, from my point of view, there is NOT enough time in the day to both survive and worry about the existence of god, even if you are retired and living on a guaranteed source of income.

                                                      • Simon, the Senior
                                                        Simon, the Senior  6 days back

                                                        Sorry! This is NOT a debate. It is just a random cut and splice of random thoughts.

                                                        • Jungle Jargon
                                                          Jungle Jargon  6 days back

                                                          Powers exist and all power comes from the Maker of everything there is so God is good because He can remake you again and prove whether you are good or evil.

                                                          • Ravy Po
                                                            Ravy Po  7 days back

                                                            If there is a God, than their has to be a Devil.

                                                            • Ravy Po
                                                              Ravy Po  6 days back

                                                              PineAppleCram He created the devil so therefore he is also the devil lol can’t argue with that

                                                            • PineAppleCram
                                                              PineAppleCram  6 days back

                                                              If there is a God, he is the Devil

                                                          • james grannes
                                                            james grannes  7 days back

                                                            Agree with a lot of his arguments,but I can,t get the Holy Spirit out of my life. President trump now has a space force, when the time comes, when aliens land, the worlds history changes at that moment, hopefully they will be friendly and we will forced to join them in the peace of the universe.

                                                            • A Estrada
                                                              A Estrada  7 days back

                                                              Actually, because we don’t understand we don’t just say because God created it. As a believer of God, we still do science research. God is greater than science, science is just a small piece of existence.

                                                              • Spritzer AK4U
                                                                Spritzer AK4U  4 days back

                                                                @halcyon1009that's what it really comes down to.

                                                              • halcyon1009
                                                                halcyon1009  4 days back

                                                                What is your definition of God and definition of Science out of curiosity?

                                                            • Sonjay Gouda
                                                              Sonjay Gouda  7 days back

                                                              Her voice 💕

                                                              • R. Toby Richards
                                                                R. Toby Richards  7 days back

                                                                6:18 is that Pat Robertson?

                                                                • Alvin Barrios
                                                                  Alvin Barrios  7 days back

                                                                  Earth is 4k years old

                                                                  Come fite me!

                                                                  • Alvin Barrios
                                                                    Alvin Barrios  7 days back

                                                                    Earth is 4k years old

                                                                    Come fite me!

                                                                    • Nonya Business
                                                                      Nonya Business  1 weeks back

                                                                      Egg or chicken? Which came first?? As a rational human, I believe in a supreme being. The Universe is my God. Out of her womb we came and in her cold abyss we shall return.

                                                                      • Dwayne Shaw
                                                                        Dwayne Shaw  3 days back

                                                                        The egg came first - then chickens evolved

                                                                    • M Jave
                                                                      M Jave  1 weeks back

                                                                      Why god is only good to rich people, rich countries, rich religious celebrities well-off folks and not for poor and less intelligent or not so good looking or Handycaps or physically challenged? Half of world population lives in poverty, in filth with no clean water.

                                                                      • TheVideoBarron
                                                                        TheVideoBarron  1 weeks back

                                                                        Seems like there’s a energy that’s driving the universe to continually collapse upon itself that’s far beyond any humans control.

                                                                        Religions around the world have reused folklore to evolve a philosophy of basic human understanding of their place in nature.

                                                                        If life or existence is easier for you to sum this up than the age old expression of god then cool.

                                                                        Existence is both good and bad, life is up and down, ying and yang.

                                                                        If you’re looking for a bearded dude in the clouds, that’s the unicorn.

                                                                        • Spritzer AK4U
                                                                          Spritzer AK4U  4 days back

                                                                          @MrLasNinjas I'm guessing he's talking about the idea that the big bang is real and we observe black holes and such. So with black holes that pull an pull everything to a point, a point that doesn't look to fit it's mass. We have a big bang then everything eventually is pulled together and starts all over again.

                                                                        • MrLasNinjas
                                                                          MrLasNinjas  5 days back

                                                                          TheVideoBarron what energy are you talking about? The universe is continually expanding and the acceleration is continually increasing. There is literally not enough mass, dark matter or visible matter, to keep the universe from expanding.

                                                                      • M Jave
                                                                        M Jave  1 weeks back

                                                                        That’s why Neil got in trouble of courts because he insulted religious celebrities and they put him in his place by few heavenly women💃🤣

                                                                        • ThumperOne
                                                                          ThumperOne  1 weeks back

                                                                          8:11 God is dark matter which holds the universe together. Okay... LOL

                                                                          • Israfael D.
                                                                            Israfael D.  1 weeks back

                                                                            Pure and simple: God has set the laws into motion to govern the universe.
                                                                            He works within his laws, so if diseases happens or world disasters; its within those laws.
                                                                            You can't expect him to intervene for everything; that would be pointless and un-challenging.
                                                                            So much like the owner of the company who does not interact with his employees, except through his policies, managers, supervisors, and HR.

                                                                            • Israfael D.
                                                                              Israfael D.  4 days back

                                                                              @halcyon1009 the main idea is, science started in belief and gradually over the years started peeling reality with studies.
                                                                              I'm pro science, but science also has its flaws
                                                                              For instance; tomorrow you hear that coffee is good for you and then another scientist says, no it's not good for you.
                                                                              They always contradict one another unfortunately. And this is just coffee!

                                                                              I agree with you, bible is interpreted by people in their suit.
                                                                              I believe there's only one God. This is just personal belief.
                                                                              Actually many religions do agree with one God, it's just they have their own myth about it. But the idea is the same.

                                                                            • halcyon1009
                                                                              halcyon1009  4 days back

                                                                              @Israfael D. Except lots of scientific studies point at the idea of dark energy and this is an idea created by some of the most intellectual people specialising in that field.

                                                                              With God, he is preached by people who cannot decide on which book is correct, how many Gods there are, what his/her name is. Very little is agreed and on top of that many religious people dont even know the bible very well and interpret it differently.

                                                                              So its not really the same.. having belief in one or the other is very different and based on very different ways of thinking/ logic and cognitive processing.

                                                                            • Autistic Gamer 9LIVES
                                                                              Autistic Gamer 9LIVES  5 days back

                                                                              @Israfael D. No brother. No interest in that debate. I think it holds loose biased history but I know nothing in reality apart from it's supposed to be God Teachings according to Christians.

                                                                            • Israfael D.
                                                                              Israfael D.  6 days back

                                                                              @TigRshark Let alone God; scientist say that there's an energy in the universe called "Dark energy" yet the can't prove it, but they say it's there.
                                                                              Same with God.

                                                                            • Israfael D.
                                                                              Israfael D.  6 days back

                                                                              @Autistic Gamer 9LIVES debate about a book written by men in bronze age!